Best Goodreads Alternatives

Quick answer: The StoryGraph is the best all-round Goodreads alternative for stats and mood-based recommendations. Hardcover is the pick for a modern social tracker, LibraryThing and Libib are best for cataloguing a home library, and BookWyrm suits readers who want an open-source, ad-free option.

Quick facts
Most of these services can import your Goodreads export file
Nearly all have a free tier; some add an optional paid plan
Cataloguing tools (LibraryThing, Libib) are built for collections, not social feeds
You can use more than one service at the same time

Goodreads has been the default place to track books for years, but plenty of readers now want something different. Common reasons include a dated design, recommendations that feel random, and a wish for more control over personal data. The good news is that several newer apps do one job or another better than Goodreads does.

Every pick below is a website or app, so each link goes to the service’s official site. Features and prices change, so check current details before you move your reading history.

Quick Comparison

Pick Type Best for Cost
The StoryGraph Tracker and recommender readers who love stats and moods Free, optional paid plan
Hardcover Social tracker readers who want a modern interface Free, optional supporter plan
LibraryThing Cataloguing and community collectors and serious readers Free
Libib Home library catalog home and classroom libraries Free, paid plan for organizations
Literal Social reading app readers who share highlights Free
Fable Book club app book club members Free, optional paid plan
BookWyrm Open-source social reading readers who want no ads or tracking Free
A spreadsheet or Notion template Do-it-yourself tracker tinkerers who want full control Free

What to Look For in a Goodreads Alternative

Start with what you use a tracker for. Stats lovers need detailed charts, people who want suggestions need strong recommendations, collectors need barcode scanning, and social readers need an active community. Also check that the service imports your Goodreads CSV file and works on your devices.

1. The StoryGraph

The StoryGraph is the most popular Goodreads replacement. It recommends books by mood, pace and themes you choose, and it turns your reading into clear charts by genre, page count and more. It also shows content warnings added by readers and imports a Goodreads export in a few steps.

Best for: readers who love stats and moods. Cost: Free, optional paid plan. Keep in mind: smaller social network than Goodreads.

Visit the The StoryGraph website

2. Hardcover

Hardcover is a newer tracker with a clean, fast design, custom lists, reading goals and detailed stats. It is popular with readers who want the social side of Goodreads without the clutter. It can import Goodreads data and offers an API for people who like to build their own tools.

Best for: readers who want a modern interface. Cost: Free, optional supporter plan. Keep in mind: still adding features.

Visit the Hardcover website

3. LibraryThing

LibraryThing has been around since 2005 and is built for cataloguing. It pulls data from libraries around the world, lets you tag and sort books in detail, and has active discussion groups. Its Early Reviewers program offers free advance copies to members.

Best for: collectors and serious readers. Cost: Free. Keep in mind: older-looking interface.

Visit the LibraryThing website

4. Libib

Libib lets you scan barcodes with your phone and build a catalog of books, movies, music and games. It is a favorite of teachers and families who lend books and want to know where every copy is.

Best for: home and classroom libraries. Cost: Free, paid plan for organizations. Keep in mind: not a social network.

Visit the Libib website

5. Literal

Literal focuses on the social side of reading. You can track books, save and share highlights, follow friends and run reading clubs. It also supports importing from Goodreads.

Best for: readers who share highlights. Cost: Free. Keep in mind: smaller community.

Visit the Literal website

6. Fable

Fable combines a reading tracker with book clubs, so you can discuss a book chapter by chapter with friends or join public clubs. It also lets you track what you watch, which suits readers who follow adaptations.

Best for: book club members. Cost: Free, optional paid plan. Keep in mind: built around clubs and discussion.

Visit the Fable website

7. BookWyrm

BookWyrm is a free, open-source and ad-free alternative run by volunteers on separate servers that talk to each other. You can rate and review books, set goals and follow readers on other servers. It can import a Goodreads export.

Best for: readers who want no ads or tracking. Cost: Free. Keep in mind: you join one of several community-run servers.

Visit the BookWyrm website

8. A spreadsheet or Notion template

If you want complete control, a spreadsheet or a Notion database works well. You decide which details to track, and your data stays wherever you keep it. Goodreads lets you export your library as a CSV file, which opens in any spreadsheet app as a starting point.

Best for: tinkerers who want full control. Cost: Free. Keep in mind: no automatic recommendations.

Visit the Notion website

How to Move Your Data From Goodreads

On Goodreads, open My Books, choose Import and export, and select Export Library. Goodreads emails or shows a link to a CSV file. Download it, then use the import option on your new service. Imports can take from a few minutes to a few hours, so check a few ratings and shelves afterward. Keep the CSV file as a backup in case you switch again later.

Related: How to Track Your Reading: 7 Easy Methods · How to Start a Reading Journal

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Goodreads alternative?

The StoryGraph is the most popular choice for stats and recommendations, and Hardcover is a strong pick for a modern social tracker.

Can I import my Goodreads data?

Yes. Export your library from Goodreads as a CSV file and use the import option on The StoryGraph, Hardcover, LibraryThing, BookWyrm or another service.

Are Goodreads alternatives free?

Most have a free tier. Some offer an optional paid plan with extra features.

Which alternative is best for cataloguing a home library?

LibraryThing and Libib are built for cataloguing and support barcode scanning or detailed tagging.

Leave a Comment