Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.
Quick answer: The best picture Books About Making Good Choices include What Should Danny Do? by Adir Levy and Ganit Levy, What Should Darla Do? by Adir Levy and Ganit Levy, What If Everybody Did That? by Ellen Javernick and twelve more picks chosen for story quality and age fit. Each book below has a short description, a suggested age range and who it suits best, with a comparison table to help you choose quickly.
Making good choices takes practice, and picture books help kids see how small decisions lead to big results. These stories show characters thinking before they act, owning their mistakes and choosing kindness.
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison Table
| Book | Author | Ages | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| What Should Danny Do? | Adir Levy and Ganit Levy | 4-8 | interactive readers |
| What Should Darla Do? | Adir Levy and Ganit Levy | 4-8 | fans of choose-your-path books |
| What If Everybody Did That? | Ellen Javernick | 4-8 | kids learning about rules |
| The Bad Seed | Jory John | 4-8 | kids who think they're “bad” |
| The Good Egg | Jory John | 4-8 | perfectionists |
| David Gets in Trouble | David Shannon | 3-7 | kids who make excuses |
| Clark the Shark | Bruce Hale | 4-8 | energetic kids |
| Know and Follow Rules | Cheri J. Meiners | 4-8 | classroom routines |
| Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! | Mo Willems | 3-7 | kids who test limits |
| Ruthie and the (Not So) Teeny Tiny Lie | Laura Rankin | 3-7 | honesty lessons |
| The Empty Pot | Demi | 4-8 | folktale fans |
| Lilly's Purple Plastic Purse | Kevin Henkes | 4-8 | kids who act on impulse |
| Each Kindness | Jacqueline Woodson | 5-9 | thoughtful readers |
| Be Kind | Pat Zietlow Miller | 4-8 | kids who want to help |
| The Juice Box Bully | Bob Sornson and Maria Dismondy | 5-9 | bystanders |
How We Chose These Books
We looked for real, widely available titles that match the theme and the age range, and we favoured books with clear storytelling and strong reputations with parents, teachers and librarians. Age ranges are suggestions, not rules, so you know your reader best. Previewing a book before you hand it over is always a good idea, especially for sensitive topics.
The 15 Books
1. What Should Danny Do? by Adir Levy and Ganit Levy
Kids choose what Danny does and see how each choice shapes his day. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: interactive readers.
2. What Should Darla Do? by Adir Levy and Ganit Levy
Darla's choices change the story. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: fans of choose-your-path books.
3. What If Everybody Did That? by Ellen Javernick
Small choices add up when everyone makes them. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: kids learning about rules.
4. The Bad Seed by Jory John
A seed decides to make better choices. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: kids who think they're “bad”.
5. The Good Egg by Jory John
A good egg learns to take care of itself too. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: perfectionists.
6. David Gets in Trouble by David Shannon
David finally says sorry. Recommended ages: about 3-7.
Best for: kids who make excuses.
7. Clark the Shark by Bruce Hale
Clark learns to calm down. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: energetic kids.
8. Know and Follow Rules by Cheri J. Meiners
Why rules help everyone. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: classroom routines.
9. Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! by Mo Willems
The Pigeon begs to break the rules. Recommended ages: about 3-7.
Best for: kids who test limits.
10. Ruthie and the (Not So) Teeny Tiny Lie by Laura Rankin
Ruthie's small lie grows. Recommended ages: about 3-7.
Best for: honesty lessons.
11. The Empty Pot by Demi
A boy's honesty is rewarded. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: folktale fans.
12. Lilly's Purple Plastic Purse by Kevin Henkes
Lilly regrets an angry choice. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: kids who act on impulse.
13. Each Kindness by Jacqueline Woodson
Chloe wishes she had chosen kindness. Recommended ages: about 5-9.
Best for: thoughtful readers.
14. Be Kind by Pat Zietlow Miller
A girl thinks about how to be kind. Recommended ages: about 4-8.
Best for: kids who want to help.
15. The Juice Box Bully by Bob Sornson and Maria Dismondy
Classmates choose to stand up together. Recommended ages: about 5-9.
Best for: bystanders.
How to Choose the Right Book
For preschoolers, start with Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus! and David Gets in Trouble. Kids who love interactive stories will enjoy What Should Danny Do? and What Should Darla Do?. For kindness and honesty, Each Kindness, Be Kind and The Empty Pot are excellent.
Tips for Choosing and Sharing These Books
- Read it first. A quick skim lets you spot anything that might need a conversation.
- Match the book to the child. A reader who loves jokes may prefer a funny pick, while a quiet reader may prefer a gentler story.
- Read together. Pausing to ask what a character might feel or do next turns a story into a conversation.
- Visit the library. Borrowing a few titles from this list lets you find the ones your child returns to.
- Revisit favourites. Children often ask for the same book again and again, and rereading builds confidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best book on this list to start with?
What Should Danny Do? by Adir Levy and Ganit Levy is a strong place to start, and every book on this list is a good option.
What age are these books for?
The books on this list suit roughly ages 3 to 9, and each entry shows its own suggested range.
Should I read these books aloud?
Many of them work well read aloud, especially with younger children, and older readers may enjoy reading them independently.
Where can I find these books?
Most of these titles are easy to find at public libraries, school libraries and bookshops, and many are available as ebooks or audiobooks, which can help reluctant or struggling readers.
How can I help my child make better choices?
Talk through choices before they happen, praise good decisions and calmly discuss what could be done differently next time.
Related: 15 Best Books for Kids About Making Friends · 15 Best Books on the Manhattan Project: The Making of the Atomic Bomb