Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.
Quick answer: If you like Andy Carpenter, read The Lincoln Lawyer, A Time to Kill, Presumed Innocent and Dog On It. All mix courtroom tension with sharp wit, flawed lawyers and cases that turn on a twist.
David Rosenfelt's Andy Carpenter is a wealthy, sarcastic New Jersey defence lawyer who loves his golden retriever, Tara, and only takes cases he believes in. The series is known for humour, dogs and clever endings. The books below offer legal thrillers and mysteries, some funny and some serious.
Table of Contents
Quick Picks at a Glance
| Book | Author | Ages | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open and Shut | David Rosenfelt | Adult | the series start |
| The Lincoln Lawyer | Michael Connelly | Adult | modern legal thriller |
| A Time to Kill | John Grisham | Adult | emotional courtroom |
| The Firm | John Grisham | Adult | paranoid thriller |
| The Rainmaker | John Grisham | Adult | underdog lawyer |
| Presumed Innocent | Scott Turow | Adult | prosecutor in the dock |
| Anatomy of a Murder | Robert Traver | Adult | classic courtroom |
| The Case of the Velvet Claws | Erle Stanley Gardner | Adult | Perry Mason |
| Dog On It | Spencer Quinn | Adult | dog-narrated mystery |
| Everywhere That Mary Went | Lisa Scottoline | Adult | female lawyer |
| Dead Irish | John Lescroart | Adult | San Francisco mystery |
| Guilt by Association | Marcia Clark | Adult | prosecutor's view |
| One for the Money | Janet Evanovich | Adult | comic mystery |
| To Kill a Mockingbird | Harper Lee | All ages | classic courtroom |
| Just Mercy | Bryan Stevenson | Adult | real-life justice |
1. Open and Shut by David Rosenfelt
Andy inherits a fortune, takes a case he did not expect and discovers a conspiracy. A quick, funny introduction to the series.
Best for: the series start.
2. The Lincoln Lawyer by Michael Connelly
Mickey Haller works out of his car and defends clients across Los Angeles. Sharp, fast and clever.
Best for: modern legal thriller.
3. A Time to Kill by John Grisham
A lawyer defends a father who killed his daughter's attackers. Grisham's first novel, still gripping.
Best for: emotional courtroom.
4. The Firm by John Grisham
A young lawyer finds his dream job hides a dangerous secret. Pure page-turner.
Best for: paranoid thriller.
5. The Rainmaker by John Grisham
A new lawyer takes on a powerful insurance company. Lighter and funnier than some Grisham.
Best for: underdog lawyer.
6. Presumed Innocent by Scott Turow
A prosecutor is accused of murdering a colleague. Dense and brilliant, with a famous ending.
Best for: prosecutor in the dock.
7. Anatomy of a Murder by Robert Traver
A small-town lawyer defends a soldier accused of murder. A classic of the genre, based on the author's own experience.
Best for: classic courtroom.
8. The Case of the Velvet Claws by Erle Stanley Gardner
The first Perry Mason novel, with a lawyer who defends the accused and finds the real culprit. Quick and plotty.
Best for: Perry Mason.
9. Dog On It by Spencer Quinn
Chet, a dog, narrates the cases of his human partner Bernie. Funny, warm and very doggy.
Best for: dog-narrated mystery.
10. Everywhere That Mary Went by Lisa Scottoline
Mary DiNunzio, a Philadelphia lawyer, is stalked by a mysterious figure. Funny and tense.
Best for: female lawyer.
11. Dead Irish by John Lescroart
A lawyer-turned-bartender is pulled into a murder involving an old friend. Character-driven and well plotted.
Best for: San Francisco mystery.
12. Guilt by Association by Marcia Clark
A Los Angeles prosecutor investigates a case that hits close to home. Written by a former real-life prosecutor.
Best for: prosecutor's view.
13. One for the Money by Janet Evanovich
Stephanie Plum becomes a bounty hunter and stumbles through her first case. Fast, funny and light.
Best for: comic mystery.
14. To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
Atticus Finch defends a Black man falsely accused in 1930s Alabama. A classic of conscience and justice.
Best for: classic courtroom.
15. Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson
A young lawyer fights wrongful convictions in Alabama. Moving non-fiction with real courtroom drama.
Best for: real-life justice.
How to Choose
For funny, lighthearted mysteries pick Dog On It or One for the Money. For fast modern thrillers choose Michael Connelly or John Grisham. For classic courtroom drama try To Kill a Mockingbird, Anatomy of a Murder or Perry Mason. For true stories read Just Mercy. If you want to stay with Rosenfelt, begin at Open and Shut and keep going in order, since characters evolve across the books. Many of these authors also write long-running series, so you can keep reading for months. If dogs are your main draw, Dog On It is the best match. If you want courtroom tension, begin with A Time to Kill or Presumed Innocent. Most have audiobook versions with strong narrators.
Related: 15 Books Like Wings of Fire Kids Will Love: Dragons, Quests and Animal Adventures · 12 Dystopian Books Like the Hunger Games | Best Books to Read Like Hunger Games
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Andy Carpenter?
A New Jersey defence lawyer and dog lover in David Rosenfelt's mystery series.
Where should I start?
With Open and Shut, the first book.
Is it a funny series?
Yes, with sarcastic narration and plenty of dog scenes.
Is it a legal thriller or a cozy?
It sits between them. The cases are serious but the tone is light.
How many books are there?
More than twenty. Check current listings for the latest count.
Do I need to read in order?
Not strictly, but the characters develop.
Is Tara in every book?
The dog features throughout the series, but she is more prominent in some than others.
Are there audiobooks?
Yes, for many titles. Check current listings.
Does Andy Carpenter have a dog?
Yes, a golden retriever named Tara, and the series also involves a dog rescue foundation.
What if I want more courtroom scenes?
Try A Time to Kill, Presumed Innocent or Anatomy of a Murder.