Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.
Quick answer: Good book club questions for If We Were Villains focus on mystery, roles and identity and shakespeare and style. Below are 18 questions grouped by theme, with a spoiler-free summary, a characters-and-themes table, meeting ideas and a sample 90-minute plan.
Quick facts
– Book: If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio
– First published: 2017
– Setting: A conservatory in Illinois
– Adaptation: None
– Content note: Murder, drinking
If We Were Villains is a rewarding choice for a book club because it gives readers plenty to discuss without needing special knowledge. This guide gives you questions you can use as written or adapt for your group, plus ideas for running the meeting, so that a host with little time can still lead a good conversation.
Table of Contents
Spoiler-Free Summary
Oliver Marks gets out of prison after ten years for a murder he may or may not have committed. A detective wants the truth about what happened at the conservatory where Oliver and six actors studied Shakespeare.
Check price of If We Were Villains on Amazon
Main Characters and Themes
| Character or Theme | What to Know |
|---|---|
| Oliver Marks | The narrator |
| James Farrow | The group's leader |
| Richard Stanley | A key rival |
| Shakespeare | The group's language |
Discussion Questions (Contains Spoilers)
These questions assume everyone has finished the book, so they discuss the ending. They are grouped by theme so you can move through them in order or jump to the topic your group cares about most. Feel free to rephrase them, add follow-up questions such as “why do you think so?” and skip any that do not suit your members.
Opening Reactions
- What was your first impression of If We Were Villains, and did it change as you read?
- Which scene or passage stayed with you most, and why?
Mystery
- What did you suspect about the murder?
- Did Oliver tell the truth?
- How does the five-act structure shape the story?
- What did the ending reveal?
Roles and Identity
- How do the typecast roles shape the group?
- Is Oliver a reliable narrator?
- What do the characters hide?
- Who do you think is the villain?
Shakespeare and Style
- How does Shakespeare influence the story?
- Did you need to know the plays?
- What did you think of the prose?
- How does the book compare with The Secret History?
Looking Back
- How did the ending of If We Were Villains make you feel, and was it the ending you expected?
- Would you recommend this book to a friend, and what would you tell them first?
- If you could ask M. L. Rio one question, what would it be?
Meeting Ideas
Serve British pub-style food and read favorite Shakespeare lines aloud. Ask each guest to pick a role.
A simple way to start is to have each person share a one-sentence rating of the book before discussion begins. It surfaces disagreements early and gives quieter members a chance to speak first. You can also ask each member to bring one question of their own, which often leads to the best conversations of the night.
Ways to Make the Discussion Richer
- Compare formats. If a film, series or stage version of If We Were Villains exists, discuss what changes and why.
- Share a favorite line. Ask each person to read a short passage that stood out and explain what it meant to them.
- Cast the book. Ask the group who they would cast in the main roles, and why.
- Rate the pace. Ask where the book felt fastest or slowest, and whether the structure worked for them.
- Pair it with a snack or drink. Food connected to the story gives guests something to talk about before the formal discussion starts.
Tips for Leading the Discussion
- Prepare, but stay flexible. Pick a handful of questions in advance and let the group's reactions guide you.
- Invite quieter voices. Ask someone who has not spoken to share a favorite line or scene.
- Welcome disagreement. A lively debate about a character is a sign that the book is working.
- Return to the text. Ask members to point to a passage in If We Were Villains that supports their view.
- Watch the clock. Move on when a question has run its course, and save extra questions for another time.
If your group has only an hour, choose one question from each theme and skip the rest.
Is If We Were Villains a Good Book Club Pick?
A dark, intense pick for fans of The Secret History. Some knowledge of Shakespeare helps but is not required.
Books Like This One
- The Secret History by Donna Tartt: a campus murder
- Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo: dark academia fantasy
How to Structure Your Meeting
A 90-minute meeting works well in four parts:
- Welcome and quick ratings (10 minutes). Settle in and share a one-line reaction.
- Spoiler-free talk (20 minutes). Start with characters, setting and style before the plot.
- Spoiler discussion (45 minutes). Work through three or four of the questions above, letting the conversation wander when it is productive.
- Wrap-up (15 minutes). Share favorite lines, choose the next book and thank the host.
If the conversation is going well, it is fine to let it run long and skip some questions.
After the Meeting
Send a short follow-up message with the next title, the date and a link to any readings or articles that came up. Some groups keep a simple record of books read and ratings, which makes it easier to choose future picks and spot the kinds of books the group loves most.
Related: If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio: Summary and Key Takeaways · 15 Books Like If We Were Villains You’ll Love: Shakespeare, Theatre and Dark Friendships
Frequently Asked Questions
How many questions should we prepare for If We Were Villains?
Five to eight is enough for a 90-minute meeting. This guide gives eighteen, so you can choose the ones that fit your group.
Does If We Were Villains work as a first pick for a new book club?
A dark, intense pick for fans of The Secret History.
Do I need to know Shakespeare?
No.
Is it YA?
No.
What if some members have not finished If We Were Villains?
Start with the spoiler-free questions and a short plot recap, then move to the spoiler section only when most people have finished.