Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.
Spoiler warning: some character descriptions below mention events from the whole of Sarah, Plain and Tall, including the ending.
Quick answer: The main characters in Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan are Anna Witting, Caleb Witting, Jacob Witting (Papa) and Sarah Wheaton. Below you'll find who each character is, what role they play and how they connect to one another.
Quick facts
- Book: Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan
- First published: 1985
- Main character: Anna Witting
- Characters covered: 8
Table of Contents
What Sarah, Plain and Tall Is About
On a farm on the American prairie in the late 1800s, Anna and her younger brother Caleb live with their father, Jacob Witting, whose wife died the day after Caleb was born. The house has been quiet and sad for years. Then Papa places an advertisement for a wife, and Sarah Wheaton, a woman from Maine, answers. She writes that she is “plain and tall” and agrees to come for a month to see if she likes them. Anna and Caleb fall in love with Sarah, but they fear she misses the sea too much to stay.

Check price of Sarah, Plain and Tall on Amazon
Character List at a Glance
| Character | Role |
|---|---|
| Anna Witting | Narrator |
| Caleb Witting | Brother |
| Jacob Witting (Papa) | Father |
| Sarah Wheaton | Newcomer |
| Seal | Sarah's cat |
| William | Sarah's brother |
| Maggie and Matthew | Neighbours |
| Mattie, Lou and Harriet | Sarah's aunts |
The Main Characters Explained
Anna Witting
Narrator. A quiet, thoughtful girl who remembers her mother and longs for Sarah to stay. She is careful about hoping.
Caleb Witting
Brother. Anna's cheerful little brother, who constantly asks about their mother and whether Sarah is happy.
Jacob Witting (Papa)
Father. A kind, lonely farmer who stopped singing after his wife died.
Sarah Wheaton
Newcomer. An independent, honest woman from Maine who loves the sea. She learns to drive the wagon and fix the roof.
Seal
Sarah's cat. The grey cat Sarah brings from Maine.
William
Sarah's brother. Sarah's brother back in Maine, a fisherman.
Maggie and Matthew
Neighbours. A neighbouring farm couple who help Sarah feel at home.
Mattie, Lou and Harriet
Sarah's aunts. Sarah's elderly aunts in Maine.
How the Characters Connect
The family's grief and hope centre on Sarah, who brings colour, song and courage to the prairie. Maggie shows Sarah that one can love a new place without forgetting home. When Sarah drives alone to town, the children fear she has left, but she returns with coloured pencils to draw the sea. The book won the Newbery Medal in 1986.
Tips for Keeping Track of the Characters
- Note first appearances. Jot down a line about each character the first time they appear.
- Track relationships. A simple map of who is related to, friends with or against whom makes later chapters easier.
- Watch for change. Ask how each main character is different at the end compared with the beginning.
- Use this guide as a check. Come back to the table above if a name slips your mind mid-read.
How to Write About a Character in Sarah, Plain and Tall
If you are writing an essay or preparing for class, these steps help:
- Choose one character. A focused study is stronger than a summary of everyone.
- Track key moments. Note the scenes where the character makes an important choice or changes.
- Look at relationships. Explain how other characters reveal who this person really is.
- Use specific evidence. Quote or describe exact actions and words, then explain what they show.
- Connect to the bigger picture. Ask what the character teaches readers about the book's main ideas.
Discussion Questions
- Which character in Sarah, Plain and Tall changes the most, and what causes the change?
- Is Anna Witting a reliable guide to the story, or do you see things they miss?
- Which minor character would you most like to hear more from, and why?
- Which relationship in the book feels most realistic to you?
Books With Memorable Characters Like These
- Skylark by Patricia MacLachlan
- Caddie Woodlawn by Carol Ryrie Brink
Related: Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan: Summary and Key Takeaways · Sarah, Plain and Tall Ending Explained
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the main character in Sarah, Plain and Tall?
The main character is Anna Witting (narrator).
How many main characters are in Sarah, Plain and Tall?
This guide covers 8 key characters, though the book includes others in smaller roles.
Who wrote Sarah, Plain and Tall?
Sarah, Plain and Tall was written by Patricia MacLachlan and first published in 1985.
What should I read after Sarah, Plain and Tall?
Try Skylark by Patricia MacLachlan or Caddie Woodlawn by Carol Ryrie Brink.