How to Choose Book Club Books (Without the Arguments)

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn’t change our picks or your price.

Quick answer: To choose book club books, look for titles that are easy to find, not too long and full of things to discuss, like complex characters or moral dilemmas. Then use a fair selection system, such as rotating picks, voting from a shortlist or monthly themes, so everyone feels heard.

Quick facts
Ideal length: 250 to 400 pages
Best mix: alternate fiction, nonfiction and genres
Plan ahead: choose 2 to 3 months at a time
Check: library availability and paperback price

Choosing the next book is one of the most common sources of book club tension. Pick something too long and half the group won’t finish. Pick something too light and there’s nothing to discuss. Let the same person choose every time and others feel left out. The secret is to know what makes a great book club book and to use a fair system for picking it.

What Makes a Good Book Club Book?

  • Discussable: complex characters, moral gray areas, a surprising ending or big themes.
  • Accessible: available at the library, in paperback or as an ebook or audiobook.
  • Reasonable length: about 250 to 400 pages for a monthly club.
  • Engaging: a story people actually want to finish.
  • Not too divisive or extreme for your group, unless that’s your style.

Popular examples include The Vanishing Half, Lessons in Chemistry and Remarkably Bright Creatures. They’re readable, and they leave plenty to talk about.

Check price of The Vanishing Half on Amazon

5 Fair Ways to Pick Book Club Books

1. Rotate the pick

Each member takes turns choosing the book, often the same person who hosts. It’s simple and fair, and it exposes the group to different tastes.

2. Vote from a shortlist

The host or a volunteer suggests three to five books, and members vote by poll or in person. This works well for groups that want everyone to have a say.

3. Use themes

Choose a theme for the month or season, like translated fiction, memoirs, banned books or summer reads, then pick a book within it. Themes make choosing easier and add variety.

4. Plan a year at a time

Some clubs meet once a year to choose all 12 books. It’s great for busy members who want to read ahead.

5. Follow a list

Pick from award winners, celebrity book clubs or curated lists, like our best book club books of all time.

Where to Find Book Club Ideas

Look at prize winners like the Pulitzer, Booker and National Book Award; celebrity clubs like Reese’s Book Club and Read with Jenna; your library’s book club kits; publisher reading guides; and genre lists for mysteries, historical fiction and more.

Mistakes to Avoid

  • Choosing very long books without allowing extra time.
  • Picking only one genre and boring half the group.
  • Ignoring availability, like brand-new hardcovers with long library waitlists.
  • Skipping content notes for books with heavy themes.
  • Letting one person always decide.

Tip: if cost is a concern, look for paperbacks or ebooks, or check your library’s app. An e-reader like the Kindle Paperwhite makes it easy to borrow library ebooks.

Questions to Ask Before Picking a Book

  • Is it available at the library or in paperback?
  • Can most members finish it in a month?
  • Will it give us more to talk about than “I liked it”?
  • Does it include content some members might want to avoid?
  • Is it different from the last few books we read?

A Sample Year of Book Club Picks

Month Theme Example Pick
January Feel-good fresh start A Man Called Ove
February Love story Persuasion
March Women’s stories Lessons in Chemistry
April Nonfiction The Boys in the Boat
May Memoir Crying in H Mart
June Beach read Beach Read
July Translated fiction Convenience Store Woman
August Thriller The Guest List
September Classic Rebecca
October Spooky Frankenstein
November Historical fiction The Nightingale
December Cozy The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society

Picks That Almost Always Work

If your group can’t agree, these crowd-pleasers rarely disappoint: A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman for humor and heart, Educated by Tara Westover for a gripping memoir, The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid for glamour and secrets, The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman for a cozy mystery, and The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah for emotional historical fiction.

How to Handle Disagreements Over Picks

If members keep clashing over choices, make the system more transparent. Let everyone suggest books in a shared list, vote anonymously, and agree that the winning book is final for that month. Alternate between lighter and heavier picks, and remember that reading something outside your comfort zone is part of the fun of being in a club.

Whatever system you choose, write it down and share it with new members, so everyone knows how the next pick will be made and when it’s their turn to suggest something.

Related: How to Choose Your Next Book · What is the Best Device For Audio Books? Top 10 to Choose From

Frequently Asked Questions

How do book clubs choose books?

Most clubs rotate who picks, vote from a shortlist, use monthly themes or plan the year ahead together.

How long should a book club book be?

For a monthly club, 250 to 400 pages works best. Split longer books over two meetings.

What makes a book good for discussion?

Complex characters, moral dilemmas, surprising endings and big themes give a group plenty to debate.

Should book clubs read new releases?

They can, but new hardcovers can be expensive and have long library waitlists, so many clubs choose books that are already out in paperback.

How far ahead should a book club choose books?

Choosing two or three months ahead gives members time to find copies, join library waitlists and read at their own pace. Some clubs plan the whole year in one meeting.

Should book clubs read books in a series?

It’s usually best to stick with standalones or first books in a series, so new members can join anytime without needing to catch up.

Leave a Comment