Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.
Spoiler warning: this analysis discusses the whole book, including the ending of If We Were Villains.
Quick answer: The main themes in If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio are art and reality, guilt and responsibility, friendship and rivalry, identity and tragedy. Each is explained below with what it means, how it develops in the story and questions you can use for study or discussion.
Quick facts
- Book: If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio
- First published: 2017
- Main themes: art and reality, guilt and responsibility, friendship and rivalry, identity and tragedy
Table of Contents
About If We Were Villains
Oliver Marks has just been released from prison after ten years. The detective who arrested him, now retired, wants the truth about what happened. Oliver tells the story of his final year at the elite Dellecher Classical Conservatory, where seven acting students studied only Shakespeare. As their roles onstage begin to bleed into real life, rivalry and jealousy grow, until one of them is found dead and the others are trapped by guilt and loyalty.

Check price of If We Were Villains on Amazon
The Main Themes in If We Were Villains
1. Art and reality
The students live and breathe Shakespeare, and their lines begin to shape their lives. Rio shows how art can blur into reality and how roles can take over identity.
Question to consider: Where in If We Were Villains does art and reality matter most to the characters, and what does M.L. Rio want readers to think about it?
2. Guilt and responsibility
Oliver takes the blame for a crime and serves ten years. The novel asks who is truly responsible and what loyalty costs.
Question to consider: Where in If We Were Villains does guilt and responsibility matter most to the characters, and what does M.L. Rio want readers to think about it?
3. Friendship and rivalry
The seven students are close but competitive. Their friendship is intense and fragile, ending in betrayal and tragedy.
Question to consider: Where in If We Were Villains does friendship and rivalry matter most to the characters, and what does M.L. Rio want readers to think about it?
4. Identity
Each actor is typecast as a hero, villain or fool. The novel explores how people become the roles others give them.
Question to consider: Where in If We Were Villains does identity matter most to the characters, and what does M.L. Rio want readers to think about it?
5. Tragedy
Like a Shakespeare play, the story moves toward disaster. Rio uses tragic structure to show that flaws can lead to destruction.
Question to consider: Where in If We Were Villains does tragedy matter most to the characters, and what does M.L. Rio want readers to think about it?
Symbols and Motifs
- The stage. It represents performance and blurred reality.
- The Shakespeare roles. They symbolise identity and fate.
- The lake. It stands for hidden truth and death.
- The prison. It represents guilt and sacrifice.
How the Themes Connect
Art and reality blur, and that blurring drives the characters toward tragedy. Friendship and rivalry heighten the tension, while guilt keeps them bound together. Identity explains why each student behaves as they do.
How to Write About the Themes of If We Were Villains
If you are writing an essay or preparing for class, these steps help:
- Pick one theme. A focused argument is stronger than a list of everything.
- Find evidence in the text. Point to specific scenes, characters and choices rather than general impressions.
- Explain, don't just describe. After each example, say what it shows about the theme.
- Connect to the ending. Ask how the final chapters resolve or complicate the theme.
- Consider other readings. A fair essay acknowledges that readers can disagree.
Discussion Questions
- Which of the themes above feels most relevant to your own life, and why?
- Do the characters in If We Were Villains handle art and reality well or badly?
- How does the title relate to the themes of the book?
- Would the story change if it were set in a different time or place?
- What does M.L. Rio leave unresolved, and why might that be?
Books With Similar Themes
- The Secret History by Donna Tartt
- Bunny by Mona Awad
Related: If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio: Summary and Key Takeaways · If We Were Villains Ending Explained
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main theme of If We Were Villains?
The central theme is art and reality, supported by guilt and responsibility and friendship and rivalry.
How many themes does If We Were Villains have?
This guide covers 5 main themes, but readers may find others.
Who wrote If We Were Villains?
If We Were Villains was written by M.L. Rio and first published in 2017.
Is If We Were Villains a good book for studying themes?
Yes. Its themes are clear enough to follow and rich enough to support essays and group discussion.
What should I read after If We Were Villains?
Try The Secret History by Donna Tartt or Bunny by Mona Awad.