Themes in Sarah, Plain and Tall Explained

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Bookish Wisdom earns from qualifying purchases. This doesn't change our picks or your price.

Spoiler warning: this analysis discusses the whole book, including the ending of Sarah, Plain and Tall.

Quick answer: The main themes in Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan are family and belonging, loss and grief, home and longing, independence and hope and fear. Each is explained below with what it means, how it develops in the story and questions you can use for study or discussion.

Quick facts

  • Book: Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan
  • First published: 1985
  • Main themes: family and belonging, loss and grief, home and longing, independence and hope and fear

About Sarah, Plain and Tall

On the Kansas prairie in the late 1800s, Anna and her little brother Caleb live with their father, Jacob, a quiet farmer whose wife died the day after Caleb was born. Since then, no one in the house sings. Jacob places a newspaper advertisement for a wife, and Sarah Wheaton of Maine answers, describing herself in a letter as plain and tall. She agrees to come for a month to see whether she likes them.

Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan book cover

Check price of Sarah, Plain and Tall on Amazon

The Main Themes in Sarah, Plain and Tall

1. Family and belonging

Anna and Caleb long for a mother, and Jacob for a partner. Sarah's arrival tests whether strangers can become a family. Her final choice to stay shows that family can be built from love and choice, not only from blood.

Question to consider: Where in Sarah, Plain and Tall does family and belonging matter most to the characters, and what does Patricia MacLachlan want readers to think about it?

2. Loss and grief

The family still grieves Anna and Caleb's mother, and Anna remembers her more than Caleb does. Sarah's presence brings back singing and laughter, showing that grief can make room for new happiness without erasing the past.

Question to consider: Where in Sarah, Plain and Tall does loss and grief matter most to the characters, and what does Patricia MacLachlan want readers to think about it?

3. Home and longing

Sarah misses the sea, her brother and the colors of Maine. She must decide whether the wide, dry prairie can become home. The novel shows that home is about people as much as place.

Question to consider: Where in Sarah, Plain and Tall does home and longing matter most to the characters, and what does Patricia MacLachlan want readers to think about it?

4. Independence

Sarah drives the wagon to town alone, wears overalls and insists on doing work usually done by men. Her independence surprises the family but earns their respect.

Question to consider: Where in Sarah, Plain and Tall does independence matter most to the characters, and what does Patricia MacLachlan want readers to think about it?

5. Hope and fear

The children watch every sign of Sarah's mood, hoping she will stay and fearing she will leave. MacLachlan captures how children read adults' feelings.

Question to consider: Where in Sarah, Plain and Tall does hope and fear matter most to the characters, and what does Patricia MacLachlan want readers to think about it?

Symbols and Motifs

  • The sea. The sea represents Sarah's past, her freedom and what she would give up by staying.
  • The colored pencils. Sarah's gift of colored pencils, which include the blue, gray and green of the sea, represents her decision to bring her old home into her new one.
  • The shells. Sarah's shells represent memory and the beauty of the place she came from.
  • The haystack dune. Jacob builds a haystack 'dune' for Sarah to slide down, a loving way of giving her a piece of the sea.

How the Themes Connect

The themes connect through the slow building of a new family. Loss leaves a silence in the house, and Sarah's independence and longing for home make her choice to stay powerful and freely made. Sarah, Plain and Tall won the Newbery Medal in 1986.

How to Write About the Themes of Sarah, Plain and Tall

If you are writing an essay or preparing for class, these steps help:

  1. Pick one theme. A focused argument is stronger than a list of everything.
  2. Find evidence in the text. Point to specific scenes, characters and choices rather than general impressions.
  3. Explain, don't just describe. After each example, say what it shows about the theme.
  4. Connect to the ending. Ask how the final chapters resolve or complicate the theme.
  5. Consider other readings. A fair essay acknowledges that readers can disagree.

Discussion Questions

  • Which of the themes above feels most relevant to your own life, and why?
  • Do the characters in Sarah, Plain and Tall handle family and belonging well or badly?
  • How does the title relate to the themes of the book?
  • Would the story change if it were set in a different time or place?
  • What does Patricia MacLachlan leave unresolved, and why might that be?

Books With Similar Themes

Related: Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan: Summary and Key Takeaways · Sarah, Plain and Tall Characters: A Complete Guide

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main theme of Sarah, Plain and Tall?

The central theme is family and belonging, supported by loss and grief and home and longing.

How many themes does Sarah, Plain and Tall have?

This guide covers 5 main themes, but readers may find others.

Who wrote Sarah, Plain and Tall?

Sarah, Plain and Tall was written by Patricia MacLachlan and first published in 1985.

Is Sarah, Plain and Tall a good book for studying themes?

Yes. Its themes are clear enough to follow and rich enough to support essays and group discussion.

What should I read after Sarah, Plain and Tall?

Try Little House on the Prairie by Laura Ingalls Wilder or Skylark by Patricia MacLachlan.

Leave a Comment